Tuesday, May 14, 2019

The Affordable Care Act and the 5th Amendment

Most of us know that the individual mandate of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) was deemed Constitutional by the SCOTUS when Chief Justice John Roberts determined that the penalty for not having health insurance functioned more like a tax and was therefore constitutional under the legislatures powers of taxation.


I understand that recently President Trump signed the tax cuts that effectively neutered the individual mandate by setting the penalty at $0. My question is this. Is asking the question on an individuals tax return asking them to violate their 5th Amendment right to not incriminate themselves? Income tax forms don't ask "are you hiding any income that you don't want to report?" In the same light, can the government ask an individual to provide information on an official document that may incriminate him/her? And if enough individuals simply opted to not answer that question, wouldn't the burden of proof be on the government to prove they did not have health insurance to begin with? Technically, in order for someone to be forced to pay the penalty, wouldn't that order come from the court, as it would if you violated income tax law?

No comments:

Post a Comment